[{"_1":2,"_842":-5,"_843":-5},"loaderData",{"_3":4,"_12":13},"root",{"_5":6,"_7":6,"_8":9,"_10":11},"isProd",true,"enableStats","domain","hyper.media","siteHost","dream-machines-2.hyper.media","routes/$",{"_14":15,"_682":683},"json",{"_16":17,"_18":19,"_20":21,"_22":-5,"_23":-5,"_24":25,"_26":-5,"_27":28,"_104":6,"_38":105,"_116":117,"_118":119,"_673":674,"_675":25,"_10":222,"_676":222,"_677":678,"_679":680},"prefersLanguages",[],"viewTerm","activity","panelParam","activity/citations","openComment","accountUid","isInspect",false,"inspectTab","document",{"_29":30,"_79":75,"_80":81,"_82":83,"_85":86,"_87":88,"_89":90,"_91":92,"_95":96,"_97":41,"_98":99,"_102":103},"content",[31,50,57,64,71],{"_32":33,"_34":35},"children",[],"block",{"_36":37,"_38":39,"_40":41,"_42":43,"_44":45,"_46":47,"_48":49},"type","Paragraph","id","3Vy4enr0","revision","bafyreigufcuusndmf76vebmqsypbmwxifvty42xx3k5ulbanwpaktnstyy","attributes",{},"annotations",[],"text","Folks --","link","",{"_32":51,"_34":52},[],{"_36":37,"_38":53,"_40":41,"_42":54,"_44":55,"_46":56,"_48":49},"58zBHIiq",{},[],"Just a gentle reminder that I took some pains at the last OOPSLA to try to remind everyone that Smalltalk is not only NOT its syntax or the class library, it is not even about classes. I'm sorry that I long ago coined the term \"objects\" for this topic because it gets many people to focus on the lesser idea.",{"_32":58,"_34":59},[],{"_36":37,"_38":60,"_40":41,"_42":61,"_44":62,"_46":63,"_48":49},"RDZNzosR",{},[],"The big idea is \"messaging\" -- that is what the kernal of Smalltalk/Squeak is all about (and it's something that was never quite completed in our Xerox PARC phase). The Japanese have a small word -- ma -- for \"that which is in between\" -- perhaps the nearest English equivalent is \"interstitial\".",{"_32":65,"_34":66},[],{"_36":37,"_38":67,"_40":41,"_42":68,"_44":69,"_46":70,"_48":49},"mfNo_bJK",{},[],"The key in making great and growable systems is much more to design how its modules communicate rather than what their internal properties and behaviors should be. Think of the internet -- to live, it (a) has to allow many different kinds of ideas and realizations that are beyond any single standard and (b) to allow varying degrees of safe interoperability between these ideas.",{"_32":72,"_34":73},[],{"_36":37,"_38":74,"_40":75,"_42":76,"_44":77,"_46":78,"_48":49},"KefoVU5K","bafy2bzaceblxyttad7c3zsjeyqh7frljmonekifx5ybdwnwdkrztmavd22g6s",{},[],"If you focus on just messaging -- and realize that a good metasystem can late bind the various 2nd level architectures used in objects -- then much of the language-, UI-, and OS based discussions on this thread are really quite moot. This was why I complained at the last OOPSLA that -- whereas PARC we changed Smalltalk constantly, treating it always as a work in progress -- when ST hit the larger world, it was pretty much taken as \"something just to be learned\", as though it were Pascal or Algol. Smalltalk-80 never really was mutated into the next better versions of OO. Given the current low state of programming in general, I think this is a real mistake.","version","account","z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8","authors",[84],"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou","path","/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging","createTime","2026-03-29T16:37:23.728Z","updateTime","2026-03-29T16:40:31.474Z","metadata",{"_93":94},"name","The big idea is \"Messaging\"","detachedBlocks",{},"genesis","generationInfo",{"_97":41,"_100":101},"generation","1774802243794","visibility","PUBLIC","isLatest",{"_85":106,"_79":75,"_109":25,"_110":81,"_38":111,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5},[107,108],"alan-kay-ideas","the-big-idea-is-messaging","latest","uid","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging","blockRef","blockRange","hostname","scheme","siteHomeIcon","ipfs://bafkreicdnqkw2kf5tznxhj2xyhyjqfursxoqqwpo4n7c2itnlkqbxnpqqq","dehydratedState",{"_120":121,"_122":123},"mutations",[],"queries",[124,183,269,502,508,522,643],{"_125":126,"_178":179,"_181":182},"state",{"_127":128,"_162":163,"_164":165,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},"data",{"_36":27,"_27":129,"_38":160},{"_29":130,"_79":75,"_80":81,"_82":156,"_85":86,"_87":88,"_89":90,"_91":157,"_95":158,"_97":41,"_98":159,"_102":103},[131,136,141,146,151],{"_32":132,"_34":133},[],{"_36":37,"_38":39,"_40":41,"_42":134,"_44":135,"_46":47,"_48":49},{},[],{"_32":137,"_34":138},[],{"_36":37,"_38":53,"_40":41,"_42":139,"_44":140,"_46":56,"_48":49},{},[],{"_32":142,"_34":143},[],{"_36":37,"_38":60,"_40":41,"_42":144,"_44":145,"_46":63,"_48":49},{},[],{"_32":147,"_34":148},[],{"_36":37,"_38":67,"_40":41,"_42":149,"_44":150,"_46":70,"_48":49},{},[],{"_32":152,"_34":153},[],{"_36":37,"_38":74,"_40":75,"_42":154,"_44":155,"_46":78,"_48":49},{},[],[84],{"_93":94},{},{"_97":41,"_100":101},{"_38":111,"_110":81,"_85":161,"_79":75,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":25},[107,108],"dataUpdateCount",1,"dataUpdatedAt",1781109149188,"error","errorUpdateCount",0,"errorUpdatedAt","fetchFailureCount","fetchFailureReason","fetchMeta","isInvalidated","status","success","fetchStatus","idle","queryKey",[180,111,75,25],"ENTITY","queryHash","[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging\",\"bafy2bzaceblxyttad7c3zsjeyqh7frljmonekifx5ybdwnwdkrztmavd22g6s\",false]",{"_125":184,"_178":267,"_181":268},{"_127":185,"_162":163,"_164":266,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},{"_36":27,"_27":186,"_38":263},{"_29":187,"_79":193,"_80":81,"_82":215,"_85":49,"_87":216,"_89":217,"_91":218,"_95":223,"_97":260,"_98":261,"_102":103},[188],{"_32":189,"_34":190},[],{"_36":191,"_38":192,"_40":193,"_42":194,"_44":214,"_46":49,"_48":49},"Query","ErSUf3Wu","bafy2bzacec6k4236vofuqtszkvvuozx7eszo5b6z6scupdntfpvyke53urrji",{"_195":196,"_197":198,"_199":200,"_213":25},"columnCount",3,"style","List","query",{"_201":202,"_207":208},"includes",[203],{"_204":81,"_85":49,"_205":206},"space","mode","AllDescendants","sort",[209],{"_210":25,"_211":212},"reverse","term","UpdateTime","banner",[],[81,84],"1970-01-01T00:00:00Z","2026-06-07T09:12:27.499Z",{"_93":219,"_220":117,"_221":222},"Dream Machines","icon","siteUrl","https://dream-machines-2.hyper.media",{"_224":225},"navigation",{"_32":226,"_34":258},[227,234,240,246,252],{"_32":228,"_34":229},[],{"_36":230,"_38":231,"_48":232,"_46":233},"Link","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/lamport-ideas","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/lamport-ideas?v=bafy2bzacea7qr4ctkjgys2zwkoheoqwpaei5kdyza2bqbhsmxo2zukwhk2lw2&l","Lamport Ideas",{"_32":235,"_34":236},[],{"_36":230,"_38":237,"_48":238,"_46":239},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas?v=bafy2bzacec5n6atwxibonw2ziygzz7tf6v4ijersv5p54ilozfckl4eqfq3f6&l","Alan Kay Ideas",{"_32":241,"_34":242},[],{"_36":230,"_38":243,"_48":244,"_46":245},"gxt2rV2-_8NRZhfwfS2tx","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ted-nelson?v=bafyreihdda2sv6kceo4bboxmgw7qk56ww4amufpeo2xb3afeiollp73w4i&l","Ted Nelson",{"_32":247,"_34":248},[],{"_36":230,"_38":249,"_48":250,"_46":251},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/def","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/def?v=bafy2bzacebc6oqimb7exo5zrjbtrj7kezsdof7ukrs7efvaw5ps4yyjptncwi&l","def",{"_32":253,"_34":254},[],{"_36":230,"_38":255,"_48":256,"_46":257},"AyFf-GfpKXQDrdFWWRgS5","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ai?v=bafy2bzaceahcjbecmj6vaipa6wio25tmadzw7mpd4wj3eb636zkevu4srkfbm&l","AI",{"_36":259,"_38":224},"Group","bafyreicretvprcx75xerxzdp65qt65x4xcs6f5cxtdkeb4va6ftqgkijsi",{"_97":260,"_100":262},"1",{"_38":264,"_110":81,"_85":265,"_79":-5,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8",[],1781109149189,[180,264,-5,6],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8\",null,true]",{"_125":270,"_178":498,"_181":501},{"_127":271,"_162":163,"_164":497,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},[272,307,330,351,379,400,426,450,476],{"_36":27,"_38":273,"_85":278,"_82":279,"_87":280,"_89":285,"_288":289,"_97":290,"_79":277,"_291":292,"_295":296,"_98":303,"_305":-5,"_91":306,"_102":103},{"_38":274,"_110":81,"_85":275,"_79":277,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ted-nelson",[276],"ted-nelson","bafy2bzaceb4lj34wxlfosiebl4ay27uxul4aemdvt43h2po7d6vnkcmayl3x4.bafy2bzaceclmnaltzvkqvonswzaoq63jkgf37vuzmh3j3yej6vpckz2x6vzmg",[276],[84],{"_281":282,"_283":284},"seconds","1780813603","nanos",786000000,{"_281":286,"_283":287},"1780823676",617000000,"sortTime","2026-06-07T06:26:43.786Z","bafyreihdda2sv6kceo4bboxmgw7qk56ww4amufpeo2xb3afeiollp73w4i","breadcrumbs",[293],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},"isMissing","activitySummary",{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":301,"_302":6},"latestCommentTime","latestCommentId","commentCount","latestChangeTime",{"_281":286,"_283":287},"isUnread",{"_97":290,"_100":304},"1780813603791","redirectInfo",{"_93":245},{"_36":27,"_38":308,"_85":313,"_82":314,"_87":315,"_89":318,"_288":321,"_97":322,"_79":312,"_291":323,"_295":325,"_98":327,"_305":-5,"_91":329,"_102":103},{"_38":309,"_110":81,"_85":310,"_79":312,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ai",[311],"ai","bafy2bzacedh665nakauc4h4kpisknk2hinuwv4dmllpt6thjbsqsfeeiejaoq",[311],[84],{"_281":316,"_283":317},"1777135985",518000000,{"_281":319,"_283":320},"1778503382",481000000,"2026-04-25T16:53:05.518Z","bafyreiebaytq2oufbmck2hvq3j3kul4y4qwp67jcbxfv5chgzxqlu5lagy",[324],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":326,"_302":6},{"_281":319,"_283":320},{"_97":322,"_100":328},"1777135985524",{"_93":257},{"_36":27,"_38":331,"_85":336,"_82":337,"_87":338,"_89":341,"_288":342,"_97":335,"_79":335,"_291":343,"_295":345,"_98":347,"_305":-5,"_91":349,"_102":103},{"_38":332,"_110":81,"_85":333,"_79":335,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/the-daemon-as-a-protocol-execution-substrate",[334],"the-daemon-as-a-protocol-execution-substrate","bafyreiepq6jx7dhe32zvccmsxqx2uk7dgyafxxdw5hxnot6xxb67etdsfi",[334],[84],{"_281":339,"_283":340},"1778170439",27000000,{"_281":339,"_283":340},"2026-05-07T16:13:59.027Z",[344],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":346,"_302":6},{"_281":339,"_283":340},{"_97":335,"_100":348},"1778170439045",{"_93":350},"The Daemon as a Protocol Execution Substrate",{"_36":27,"_38":352,"_85":357,"_82":358,"_87":359,"_89":362,"_288":365,"_97":366,"_79":356,"_291":367,"_295":369,"_98":375,"_305":-5,"_91":377,"_102":103},{"_38":353,"_110":81,"_85":354,"_79":356,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/joe-armstrong-ideas",[355],"joe-armstrong-ideas","bafy2bzaced2rm7e3tgl35h35fz63koaslrvxfsixjxzoilh46stso3o6st4wk",[355],[84],{"_281":360,"_283":361},"1777651274",925000000,{"_281":363,"_283":364},"1777921587",797000000,"2026-05-01T16:01:14.925Z","bafyreifzyq4uzjw33lu6323miyprg4u63nrlwllwftu6mrkyw2ilw34vji",[368],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":370,"_298":373,"_299":163,"_300":374,"_302":6},{"_281":371,"_283":372},"1777651301",513000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6GZZaQerqMwCM",{"_281":363,"_283":364},{"_97":366,"_100":376},"1777651274930",{"_93":378},"Joe Armstrong Ideas",{"_36":27,"_38":380,"_85":385,"_82":386,"_87":387,"_89":390,"_288":391,"_97":384,"_79":384,"_291":392,"_295":394,"_98":396,"_305":-5,"_91":398,"_102":103},{"_38":381,"_110":81,"_85":382,"_79":384,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/the-dream",[383],"the-dream","bafyreiep7gerekk54odnln4qhpuub6gtyfz7ug2fz6uumrlllivqwvpapy",[383],[84],{"_281":388,"_283":389},"1777141438",320000000,{"_281":388,"_283":389},"2026-04-25T18:23:58.320Z",[393],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":395,"_302":25},{"_281":388,"_283":389},{"_97":384,"_100":397},"1777141438325",{"_93":399},"The Dream",{"_36":27,"_38":401,"_85":404,"_82":405,"_87":406,"_89":409,"_288":412,"_97":413,"_79":403,"_291":414,"_295":416,"_98":423,"_305":-5,"_91":425,"_102":103},{"_38":237,"_110":81,"_85":402,"_79":403,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},[107],"bafy2bzacedubn6z4ifbznm3c5cv7q7kpjvpdlstfjhwchrtla32k46va3genu",[107],[84,81],{"_281":407,"_283":408},"1774774039",950000000,{"_281":410,"_283":411},"1777140851",574000000,"2026-03-29T08:47:19.950Z","bafyreiazwd7kij6z27wx7erl4cw6ukjtqs5g5p5rjo33lxjxysynplq5yy",[415],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":417,"_298":420,"_299":421,"_300":422,"_302":6},{"_281":418,"_283":419},"1776671190",674000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6GPnrDPaMQUWp",2,{"_281":410,"_283":411},{"_97":413,"_100":424},"1774774039976",{"_93":239},{"_36":27,"_38":427,"_85":432,"_82":433,"_87":434,"_89":437,"_288":440,"_97":441,"_79":431,"_291":442,"_295":444,"_98":446,"_305":-5,"_91":448,"_102":103},{"_38":428,"_110":81,"_85":429,"_79":431,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/naming-and-synchronization-in-a-decentralized-computer-system",[430],"naming-and-synchronization-in-a-decentralized-computer-system","bafy2bzacealbj5lk2lqkhurhfanvgzkokvsy6zi7km4hz6n76qr63ttzvwxq4",[430],[84],{"_281":435,"_283":436},"1776273276",125000000,{"_281":438,"_283":439},"1776276625",221000000,"2026-04-15T17:14:36.125Z","bafyreieasis5q573t6jqzodvzepi2cuxhcij3k72cxhdao6cgvwwgpgpny",[443],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":445,"_302":6},{"_281":438,"_283":439},{"_97":441,"_100":447},"1776273276153",{"_93":449},"Naming and Synchronization in a Decentralized Computer System",{"_36":27,"_38":451,"_85":455,"_82":456,"_87":457,"_89":460,"_288":463,"_97":464,"_79":454,"_291":465,"_295":467,"_98":473,"_305":-5,"_91":475,"_102":103},{"_38":231,"_110":81,"_85":452,"_79":454,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},[453],"lamport-ideas","bafy2bzacea7qr4ctkjgys2zwkoheoqwpaei5kdyza2bqbhsmxo2zukwhk2lw2",[453],[84],{"_281":458,"_283":459},"1774860333",964000000,{"_281":461,"_283":462},"1774864986",577000000,"2026-03-30T08:45:33.964Z","bafyreifinpq34rckcqzbp6ove4rm7qo2ysxsvwknr7tge5xywhn7ks7z2y",[466],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":468,"_298":471,"_299":163,"_300":472,"_302":6},{"_281":469,"_283":470},"1777199564",751000000,"z6Mkm8Uq6nbJDcA5ZyQCAhocWcL6KFfJkC7fFe465ZsMa6tw/z6GV4NmofQ1eGB",{"_281":461,"_283":462},{"_97":464,"_100":474},"1774860334010",{"_93":233},{"_36":27,"_38":477,"_85":480,"_82":481,"_87":482,"_89":485,"_288":488,"_97":489,"_79":479,"_291":490,"_295":492,"_98":494,"_305":-5,"_91":496,"_102":103},{"_38":249,"_110":81,"_85":478,"_79":479,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5,"_109":6},[251],"bafy2bzacebc6oqimb7exo5zrjbtrj7kezsdof7ukrs7efvaw5ps4yyjptncwi",[251],[84],{"_281":483,"_283":484},"1774802895",474000000,{"_281":486,"_283":487},"1774802957",394000000,"2026-03-29T16:48:15.474Z","bafyreifgdoxc5x2fj32iyqww7ezt7cq5cqsy4ncsjlndbnvp76c6ctqptm",[491],{"_93":219,"_85":49,"_294":25},{"_297":-5,"_298":49,"_299":168,"_300":493,"_302":25},{"_281":486,"_283":487},{"_97":489,"_100":495},"1774802895516",{"_93":251},1781109149191,[499,264,500],"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY","Children","[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8\",\"Children\"]",{"_125":503,"_178":506,"_181":507},{"_127":504,"_162":163,"_164":505,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},[],1781109149190,[499,111,500],"[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging\",\"Children\"]",{"_125":509,"_178":519,"_181":521},{"_127":510,"_162":163,"_164":518,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},{"_511":421,"_512":168,"_513":421,"_32":168,"_514":515,"_516":517},"citations","comments","changes","authorUids",[81,84],"blocks",{},1781109149238,[520,111],"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY","[\"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging\"]",{"_125":523,"_178":641,"_181":642},{"_127":524,"_162":163,"_164":640,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},{"_36":27,"_27":525,"_38":638},{"_29":526,"_79":403,"_80":81,"_82":632,"_85":633,"_87":412,"_89":634,"_91":635,"_95":636,"_97":413,"_98":637,"_102":103},[527,538,546,554,561,569,577,585,593,601,609,617,625],{"_32":528,"_34":529},[],{"_36":530,"_38":531,"_40":532,"_42":533,"_44":536,"_46":49,"_48":537},"Embed","qQxqI2GpcX","bafy2bzaceadm6hk3ks4z2sslwauqxsa7wrcyc35lxcvcoiki4erewd5lbxcpg",{"_534":535},"view","Card",[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/data-and-procedures-together",{"_32":539,"_34":540},[],{"_36":530,"_38":541,"_40":542,"_42":543,"_44":544,"_46":49,"_48":545},"vuUnFBEji-","bafy2bzacebixicrmwhrdizn7bl36oqrwpxwhpyssgnzg62ev3xrr45oxaddgi",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects",{"_32":547,"_34":548},[],{"_36":530,"_38":549,"_40":550,"_42":551,"_44":552,"_46":49,"_48":553},"uMemzrnQEp","bafy2bzacea3dqynfw2h2mqxmplj32nyoc67tifg7veebupq5i23kdbk4o4bia",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/what-is-oop-for-alan-kay",{"_32":555,"_34":556},[],{"_36":530,"_38":557,"_40":558,"_42":559,"_44":560,"_46":49,"_48":111},"tMigsHHW5w","bafy2bzacedmj75buox6pkl5ucux5yfvl3voortthvuxzbmmms77nhxh3zxmvk",{"_534":535},[],{"_32":562,"_34":563},[],{"_36":530,"_38":564,"_40":565,"_42":566,"_44":567,"_46":49,"_48":568},"NRbD_3XDsz","bafy2bzacebgdldbwivkoqguxupxiezsup3errilyf3o5xbqzxdosnu4fpdra4",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/master-and-instances-to-activities-and-processes",{"_32":570,"_34":571},[],{"_36":530,"_38":572,"_40":573,"_42":574,"_44":575,"_46":49,"_48":576},"s_acVt1fPE","bafy2bzacea3yhwqxac5jd7rhjmeoedxy3y7kuamawy5zafx6ikw3mv3kzsyna",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/dynamic-meanings-not-static-meanings",{"_32":578,"_34":579},[],{"_36":530,"_38":580,"_40":581,"_42":582,"_44":583,"_46":49,"_48":584},"Kif3H1fUMq","bafy2bzaceddyaqp7tkpaufbwnztkzcgklxixmlkmgeddqbe3m7szucqkdly3e",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/semantic-negotiation",{"_32":586,"_34":587},[],{"_36":530,"_38":588,"_40":589,"_42":590,"_44":591,"_46":49,"_48":592},"WaNoPBvCtG","bafy2bzacecnm42frhou6a6gq4a6vfe7d522hr2deviaje3l4bexs4srozxkie",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/biological-information-processing",{"_32":594,"_34":595},[],{"_36":530,"_38":596,"_40":597,"_42":598,"_44":599,"_46":49,"_48":600},"48ehdnBoFT","bafy2bzaced52kgxzzygklugfnanmrq2vykxn7knpz2ac4bf7cxcoi3eimykpo",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-art-of-the-metaobject-protocol",{"_32":602,"_34":603},[],{"_36":530,"_38":604,"_40":605,"_42":606,"_44":607,"_46":49,"_48":608},"eux-4oxTVT","bafy2bzacec5n6atwxibonw2ziygzz7tf6v4ijersv5p54ilozfckl4eqfq3f6",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/ideas-on-systems",{"_32":610,"_34":611},[],{"_36":530,"_38":612,"_40":613,"_42":614,"_44":615,"_46":49,"_48":616},"cAuBYxum0C","bafy2bzaceaczxcws2sdbhzuw4fpciiwtnmcoqiuzpaxvdw6w26yovkqtd2q3w",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/alan-kay-on-agents",{"_32":618,"_34":619},[],{"_36":530,"_38":620,"_40":621,"_42":622,"_44":623,"_46":49,"_48":624},"yiyc2XMiwY","bafy2bzacedxqb5x3a42b7lyxv26mxuynaslud7zxgokdzepkzobowvne2jspi",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/distributed-objects-versus-rest",{"_32":626,"_34":627},[],{"_36":530,"_38":628,"_40":403,"_42":629,"_44":630,"_46":49,"_48":631},"mTb2LsA8_9",{"_534":535},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/constraint-programming",[81,84],"/alan-kay-ideas","2026-04-25T18:14:11.574Z",{"_93":239},{},{"_97":413,"_100":424},{"_38":237,"_110":81,"_85":639,"_79":-5,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5},[107],1781109149192,[180,237,-5,25],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas\",null,false]",{"_125":644,"_178":670,"_181":672},{"_127":645,"_162":163,"_164":669,"_166":-5,"_167":168,"_169":168,"_170":168,"_171":-5,"_172":-5,"_173":25,"_174":175,"_176":177},{"_36":80,"_38":646,"_91":650},{"_79":647,"_110":84,"_38":648,"_85":649,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5},"bafy2bzacecupfxbd7v5xvsqlg5tukvxe366col5exfazr3x2rnnu5vkwjsurc","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou",[],{"_93":651,"_220":652,"_653":652,"_654":655,"_221":656,"_657":49,"_658":659,"_660":49,"_661":25,"_662":663,"_664":665,"_668":-5},"Gabo H Beaumont","ipfs://bafkreifg4zwc2bidz3zuddxbld6dzeq5xfmbfhrzgx4hpj5bkxqtw6mgku","thumbnail","cover","ipfs://bafybeiguwj7jll23xgh37usasgzapg7n5x2xfbzyat3jyrdthmwv2mufe4","https://gabo.es","layout","displayPublishTime","2025-01-21","seedExperimentalLogo","showActivity","contentWidth","L","theme",{"_666":667},"headerLayout","Center","summary",1781109149240,[671,84],"ACCOUNT","[\"ACCOUNT\",\"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou\"]","ssrContentHTML","

Folks --

Just a gentle reminder that I took some pains at the last OOPSLA to try to remind everyone that Smalltalk is not only NOT its syntax or the class library, it is not even about classes. I'm sorry that I long ago coined the term "objects" for this topic because it gets many people to focus on the lesser idea.

The big idea is "messaging" -- that is what the kernal of Smalltalk/Squeak is all about (and it's something that was never quite completed in our Xerox PARC phase). The Japanese have a small word -- ma -- for "that which is in between" -- perhaps the nearest English equivalent is "interstitial".

The key in making great and growable systems is much more to design how its modules communicate rather than what their internal properties and behaviors should be. Think of the internet -- to live, it (a) has to allow many different kinds of ideas and realizations that are beyond any single standard and (b) to allow varying degrees of safe interoperability between these ideas.

If you focus on just messaging -- and realize that a good metasystem can late bind the various 2nd level architectures used in objects -- then much of the language-, UI-, and OS based discussions on this thread are really quite moot. This was why I complained at the last OOPSLA that -- whereas PARC we changed Smalltalk constantly, treating it always as a work in progress -- when ST hit the larger world, it was pretty much taken as "something just to be learned", as though it were Pascal or Algol. Smalltalk-80 never really was mutated into the next better versions of OO. Given the current low state of programming in general, I think this is a real mistake.

","enableWebSigning","origin","homeMetadata",{"_93":219,"_220":117,"_221":222},"originHomeId",{"_110":81,"_38":264,"_85":681,"_79":-5,"_112":-5,"_113":-5,"_114":-5,"_115":-5},[],"meta",{"_684":685,"_829":830},"values",{"_686":687,"_689":690,"_691":692,"_693":694,"_696":697,"_698":699,"_700":701,"_703":704,"_705":706,"_707":708,"_709":710,"_711":712,"_713":714,"_715":716,"_717":718,"_719":720,"_721":722,"_723":724,"_725":726,"_727":728,"_729":730,"_731":732,"_733":734,"_735":736,"_737":738,"_739":740,"_741":742,"_743":744,"_745":746,"_747":748,"_749":750,"_751":752,"_753":754,"_755":756,"_757":758,"_759":760,"_761":762,"_763":764,"_765":766,"_767":768,"_769":770,"_771":772,"_773":774,"_775":776,"_777":778,"_779":780,"_781":782,"_783":784,"_785":786,"_787":788,"_789":790,"_791":792,"_793":794,"_795":796,"_797":798,"_799":800,"_801":802,"_803":804,"_805":806,"_807":808,"_809":810,"_811":812,"_813":814,"_815":816,"_817":818,"_819":820,"_821":822,"_823":824,"_825":826,"_827":828},"document.generationInfo.generation",[688],"bigint","dehydratedState.queries.0.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.1.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.1.queryKey.2",[695],"undefined","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.sortTime",[702],"Date","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.createTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.updateTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.sortTime",[702],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.redirectInfo",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[688],"dehydratedState.queries.5.queryKey.2",[695],"dehydratedState.queries.6.state.data.metadata.summary",[695],"referentialEqualities",{"_686":831,"_698":832,"_713":833,"_725":834,"_741":835,"_753":836,"_769":837,"_777":838,"_783":839,"_797":840,"_811":841},[689],[705],[719],[727,733],[747],[755,761],[775],[823],[789],[803],[817],"actionData","errors"]